https://mas.to/@markwyner/115489852379410925
-
https://mas.to/@markwyner/115489852379410925
Weird how we have 'request an account' enabled and don't have nazis signing up.
'We're a huge instance so we get targeted a lot' = you're too big. You're putting growth ahead of community safety; you're saying 'yeah we're so big that nazis target us but we'll just deal with it and sometimes one might slip through the cracks and tens/hundreds/thousands of people will be exposed to this nazi' instead of 'yikes, maybe we're too big'.
-
https://mas.to/@markwyner/115489852379410925
Weird how we have 'request an account' enabled and don't have nazis signing up.
'We're a huge instance so we get targeted a lot' = you're too big. You're putting growth ahead of community safety; you're saying 'yeah we're so big that nazis target us but we'll just deal with it and sometimes one might slip through the cracks and tens/hundreds/thousands of people will be exposed to this nazi' instead of 'yikes, maybe we're too big'.
You know what MY rollercoaster is? Cleaning up after open sign-up instances (see my posts on https://www.patreon.com/c/WelshPixie1 and see what I spend most of my time doing).
'We suspended the account, of course. But not before a lot of people yelled at us.' Yeah? You've decided to have open sign ups and so nazis sometimes sign up, this is what you can expect, and people are RIGHT to yell at you for that.
'For the record, this is not preventable when registration is open.' There's your clue!!
-
You know what MY rollercoaster is? Cleaning up after open sign-up instances (see my posts on https://www.patreon.com/c/WelshPixie1 and see what I spend most of my time doing).
'We suspended the account, of course. But not before a lot of people yelled at us.' Yeah? You've decided to have open sign ups and so nazis sometimes sign up, this is what you can expect, and people are RIGHT to yell at you for that.
'For the record, this is not preventable when registration is open.' There's your clue!!
'The only way to guarantee no rogue accounts is with closed reg' Right. This is why, if you value safety over growth, you close sign ups. You can either spend your admin time cleaning up reports of nazis and dealing with the fallout from rightfully pissed off people, or you can spend that admin time going through account requests. I know I would (and do) rather spend a bit of time every day manually vetting sign ups so that the Black, disabled, queer, neurospicy, etc. people on .art are safe -
-
'The only way to guarantee no rogue accounts is with closed reg' Right. This is why, if you value safety over growth, you close sign ups. You can either spend your admin time cleaning up reports of nazis and dealing with the fallout from rightfully pissed off people, or you can spend that admin time going through account requests. I know I would (and do) rather spend a bit of time every day manually vetting sign ups so that the Black, disabled, queer, neurospicy, etc. people on .art are safe -
- instead of making bullshit 'please stop yelling at us, just be nice' posts when we DON'T take the time to do that and oops a nazi got in again!
'But we react as quickly as possible' Wouldn't need to react quickly if you had closed sign ups. Reacting quickly to a nazi getting in is not as good as simply not letting nazis in.
'Which requires reports from yโall.' Hey, don't put the moderation failures of your instance onto your community. If you can't run it safely, don't run it.
-
- instead of making bullshit 'please stop yelling at us, just be nice' posts when we DON'T take the time to do that and oops a nazi got in again!
'But we react as quickly as possible' Wouldn't need to react quickly if you had closed sign ups. Reacting quickly to a nazi getting in is not as good as simply not letting nazis in.
'Which requires reports from yโall.' Hey, don't put the moderation failures of your instance onto your community. If you can't run it safely, don't run it.
'For every nazi account you may see for a brief moment, you donโt see hundreds of others that we managed to catch before you saw it.' - 'We do tons of pre-emptive work behind the scenes.'
You're getting hundreds of nazi accounts signing up that you're spending your time swatting and 'doing tons of pre-emptive work' instead of just *closing sign ups* and spending that time vetting accounts instead??
-
'For every nazi account you may see for a brief moment, you donโt see hundreds of others that we managed to catch before you saw it.' - 'We do tons of pre-emptive work behind the scenes.'
You're getting hundreds of nazi accounts signing up that you're spending your time swatting and 'doing tons of pre-emptive work' instead of just *closing sign ups* and spending that time vetting accounts instead??
What this tells me, again, is that you care more about growth and will whine about all the hard volunteer work you have to put in in order to HAVE that growth at the risk of community safety, instead of spending LESS effort just turning on account verification, saving yourselves mod work, saving your and every community connected to yours the trauma of seeing a nazi popping up in their feed.
-
What this tells me, again, is that you care more about growth and will whine about all the hard volunteer work you have to put in in order to HAVE that growth at the risk of community safety, instead of spending LESS effort just turning on account verification, saving yourselves mod work, saving your and every community connected to yours the trauma of seeing a nazi popping up in their feed.
'It hurts me that a nazi slipped through today. Like, it crushes my soul and makes me sad. And I want for us to prevent that.'
Obviously not THAT much or you'd just close sign ups.
Preventing it is real easy. https://mas.to/admin/settings/registrations > 'approval required for sign up'.
Fucking white guys, I swear. Let a Nazi in and then it's 'oh no people yelled at me, I'm the victim, this is so sad'

-
'It hurts me that a nazi slipped through today. Like, it crushes my soul and makes me sad. And I want for us to prevent that.'
Obviously not THAT much or you'd just close sign ups.
Preventing it is real easy. https://mas.to/admin/settings/registrations > 'approval required for sign up'.
Fucking white guys, I swear. Let a Nazi in and then it's 'oh no people yelled at me, I'm the victim, this is so sad'

@welshpixie And then he goes on to say they have mods in basically every time zone. You mean mods who can go through and approve new accounts???
-
undefined Oblomov shared this topic