I hate that "If voting changed anything they'd make it illegal" quote.
Uncategorized
28
Posts
16
Posters
40
Views
-
@RobertoArchimboldi Taking veganism as an example, I can't speak for anyone else (my wife was a vegan-for-the-animals vegan first) but I went vegan first for the climate as an attempt to reduce my impact on the planet. We have both sort of converged on each other's issues over the years, but I don't think individual choices are meaningless because they're often the starting point for collective action. It's not just about what you as an individual do or don't choose to eat (buy/consume/spend your time on), sharing information on what you are doing and meeting other people doing the same is sort of what campaign networks arise out of and how people learn about issues from each other. In my experience people tend not to just wake up one morning, think "ooh I care about this" and take on an organising role cold, they start developing concerns about something and start meeting up with and learning from people who have the same concerns. And out of that campaigns like, say, plant based
@RobertoArchimboldi Universities arise - my university has a plant based catering first policy, and that didn't just happen because people spontaneously decided to form a campaign
-
Also, saying "everyone should vote" isn't the same as saying "voting should be the extent of your civic participation", any more than saying "everyone should brush their teeth" is the same as "brushing your teeth should be the only personal hygiene action you take"
Finally, in a strange convergence of my recent threads on here, just as it doesn't hurt to be gentler than maybe you need to be when moving snails, even if you believe voting won't do anything because your vote will be cancelled out who does it actually hurt to try? It literally takes 30 seconds if you have a postal vote, is every single moment of your day seriously so accounted by by doing good things for the world that 30 seconds would be wasted?
-
Finally, in a strange convergence of my recent threads on here, just as it doesn't hurt to be gentler than maybe you need to be when moving snails, even if you believe voting won't do anything because your vote will be cancelled out who does it actually hurt to try? It literally takes 30 seconds if you have a postal vote, is every single moment of your day seriously so accounted by by doing good things for the world that 30 seconds would be wasted?
@afewbugs we are lucky in UK (and presumably rest of Europe) that voting is relatively easy, polling stations are within walking distance and during last election even with all the level of social tension / polarisation I only saw *one* Police car in the whole area (probably only there because folk might have been inclined to park in daft places)
-
@afewbugs we are lucky in UK (and presumably rest of Europe) that voting is relatively easy, polling stations are within walking distance and during last election even with all the level of social tension / polarisation I only saw *one* Police car in the whole area (probably only there because folk might have been inclined to park in daft places)
@vfrmedia thinking about it polling stations are one of the few bits of infrastructure that still works well aren't they? It's easier to get to vote than it is to get a GP appointment, find a dentist, get a bus on Sundays or get a Royal Mail parcel delivered in a rural area ๐ข
-
Finally, in a strange convergence of my recent threads on here, just as it doesn't hurt to be gentler than maybe you need to be when moving snails, even if you believe voting won't do anything because your vote will be cancelled out who does it actually hurt to try? It literally takes 30 seconds if you have a postal vote, is every single moment of your day seriously so accounted by by doing good things for the world that 30 seconds would be wasted?
@afewbugs I don't object to voting, but many times I've been in activist groups that were literally told to stand down by the Democratic Party in favor of concentrating on elections, and people would listen and do it.
-
@vfrmedia thinking about it polling stations are one of the few bits of infrastructure that still works well aren't they? It's easier to get to vote than it is to get a GP appointment, find a dentist, get a bus on Sundays or get a Royal Mail parcel delivered in a rural area ๐ข
@afewbugs they are still one of the things which by necessity remain in public ownership..
-
@RobertoArchimboldi Universities arise - my university has a plant based catering first policy, and that didn't just happen because people spontaneously decided to form a campaign
@afewbugs now I agree with what you say about how campaigns happen, but it is the collective action that changes things.
There is no correlation between your decision to eschew animal products in your diet and the emissions of the farming industry or between the number of animals slaughtered and your wife's dietary choices. The industry carries on regardless. Even if lots of people go vegan, and they have, the effect on the industry is to reduce the price of animal products and thus increase consumption elsewhere. The university going plant based does not have any effect either.
Of course, there will never be a vegan future without vegans in the present. The collective action has opened up that possibility. It is made much closer as your university goes vegan. It is clear that this is a way that we collectively could live. Your choices are part of that collective action, but it is at the level of collective possibility that change is occurring.
When Goldman says that voting changes nothing. She is not saying that you shouldn't vote. She is saying, rightly in my view, that the interests of the working class as a class are not furthered by any of the political parties available to them and that the system is such that they could never be.
She is warning against two illusions. 1. That the working class should align with any section of the bourgeoise to win concessions from them. I assume that she thinks that they will just be used and discarded. 2. That the class could pursue its interests through the formation of a working class political party, like the Populist Party (People's Party) of her day. I assume that she thinks that such a party will inevitably be subsumed into one or other of the bourgeois parties, as happened to the Populist Party. Instead she wants to see independent, international revolutionary organisation by the class.
That doesn't mean that you don't vote or even use the ballot as a means to extract concessions through campaigning. She is simply pointing out that it is collective action that brings change and that the class will never liberate itself through the bourgeois political process.
Of course, you might not share Goldman's class analysis. You might also share it but be on the side of the bourgeoise. In either case, you will think that electoral politics is productive. But then it is still the campaigning and not the individual voting that matters.
You might, like the DSA, think that Goldman is wrong about 2. They do think that they can wrest control of the Democratic party for the working class, but that is a question of organising. The equivalent strategy here would probably be to try to wrest control of the Greens from the petit bourgeois. Perhaps that is happening.
This has been very helpful and interesting. I think that I am beginning to repeat myself. So I will probably leave you the last word. Thank you
-
I hate that "If voting changed anything they'd make it illegal" quote. Yes it's probably not going to change much, but the fact that governments have been actively working over the years to make it harder for trans people, people without fixed addresses or people who can't afford photo ID to vote suggests they're worried it'll change something, and by discouraging people from voting you're actively helping them with this.
@afewbugs I often think of this photo, showing voting lines for the South African general election in 1994. People fought for many decades to get to this moment.
Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
-
@Vitalba dalle bbufale in circolazione concludo che questo referendum sarร uno sfogatoio di giustizialismo classista, che vuole mandare in galera a vita i ladri di polli e dare licenza di uccidere e abusare di minorenni ai potenti nostrani e stranieri, da Al Masri a Netanyahu. Dall'altra parte, chi difende la costituzione e le sue architetture di poteri e contropoteri, e chi si ostina ancora a credere nella legge uguale per tutti e non pilotata da alcuni. Terrรฒ il fiato sospeso fino alla fine.
-
@kenobit ma questa รจ una storia meravigliosa ๐
-
@btp more importantly, what type of dog would you get? ๐ฅ
-
@filippo with a manufacture date so you know when the luck starts to wear off
-
@filippo All faces a SIX? Hmm....๐คช
-
They sell entropy sources at FamilyMart in Taiwan in convenient 51-bit packages!
-
โ๐จ๐ป ๐ฝ๐ฎ๐๐ฟ๐ถ๐บ๐ผ๐ป๐ถ๐ผ ๐ป๐ฎ๐๐ฐ๐ผ๐๐๐ผ ๐๐ผ๐ฟ๐ป๐ฎ ๐ฎ๐น๐น๐ฎ ๐น๐๐ฐ๐ฒ ๐ถ๐ป ๐ง๐๐ป๐ถ๐๐ถ๐ฎ
๐๏ธ Dagli archivi dei musei di Cartagine e del Bardo emergono straordinari intonaci dipinti di etร romana, con pigmenti preziosi e scene mitologiche.
โ Una riscoperta che restituisce colore alle domus del Nord Africa imperiale.#archeologia #Tunisia #arteRomana #Cartagine #Pompei #musei #ricerca #PNRR #UniversitadiBologna
๐ท ยฉUniBo
โก๏ธ I dettagli su Storie & Archeostorie: https://wp.me/p7tSpZ-cCA
-
@zygoloid
Suppose you have 1 KiB of memory. You ordinarily can use it to store no more than 1024 values of a std::int8_t.
Supposing we have a new data type, std::intnegative8_t, we can e.g. store 1024 of those in our memory, along with 2048 values of type std::int8_t. We have doubled how many signed bytes we can store in a fixed size block of memory, at the relatively minor cost of allocating a few additional data items as overhead.
