Skip to content

Piero Bosio Social Web Site Personale Logo Fediverso

Social Forum federato con il resto del mondo. Non contano le istanze, contano le persone

This is why the forums don’t syndicate to Mastodon

General Discussion
3 3 9
  • This is why the forums don’t syndicate to Mastodon

    Twice, in the past, I have thought it would be nice if everyone’s stuff made it out onto social media. Both times, I have enabled syndicating forum topics. Both times it went badly.

    We ended up syndicating spam that is easy to remove here, but hangs about in FediSpace forever.

    A bit like this:

    Forum spam that got syndicated out

    I’m sure there must be a way to revoke that stuff, but I’m not sure what that way is. So, until we can undo spam that gets syndicated, forum stuff will remain local only. If someone can help me figure out how to unspam social media, I think it would be nicer to take a poll to see if our active members even want our forums appearing on social media.

  • This is why the forums don’t syndicate to Mastodon

    Twice, in the past, I have thought it would be nice if everyone’s stuff made it out onto social media. Both times, I have enabled syndicating forum topics. Both times it went badly.

    We ended up syndicating spam that is easy to remove here, but hangs about in FediSpace forever.

    A bit like this:

    Forum spam that got syndicated out

    I’m sure there must be a way to revoke that stuff, but I’m not sure what that way is. So, until we can undo spam that gets syndicated, forum stuff will remain local only. If someone can help me figure out how to unspam social media, I think it would be nicer to take a poll to see if our active members even want our forums appearing on social media.

    I'd say that forums are definitely welcome and needed on the Fediverse, and can coexist well with microblog platforms like Mastodon.

    ActivityPub.Space is proof of that!

    We straddle both the microblogs and threaded discussions.

    Spam is taken care of just like everywhere else: Delete activities.

  • I'd say that forums are definitely welcome and needed on the Fediverse, and can coexist well with microblog platforms like Mastodon.

    ActivityPub.Space is proof of that!

    We straddle both the microblogs and threaded discussions.

    Spam is taken care of just like everywhere else: Delete activities.

    Agreed that forums are definitely needed, and the energy NodeBB has brought to the Fediverse has been very welcome indeed! The coexistence is often smooth but sometimes quite clunky (although of course that's true for ActivityPub platforms in general).

    Specifically for the deletes, I had also run into problems where they weren't getting propagated everywhere. Not sure if there's a similar thing happening here; If I recall correctly, the issue I was experiencing related to unsigned fetches.

    @julian


Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
Post suggeriti
  • 0 Votes
    3 Posts
    18 Views
    @pfefferle@mastodon.social I'm frankly surprised I ran into a side effect of this so soon after you updated the site :laughing: Either the PR is to be reverted or perhaps WP should handle requests to the URL encoded address :shrug: But after briefing myself on the root cause, it does seem weird that there exist actors with unicode in their ID. Might be if that is the case you should disregard them as non-compliant, who knows. cc @silverpill@mitra.social
  • 2 Votes
    6 Posts
    36 Views
    Hi @silverpill@mitra.social right; Move and Remove are explicit actions concerning membership of a context in an audience. Update is overly broad and receivers would have to infer audience change based on what the updated object contains (e.g. Audience Y is suddenly missing, and Z is new, was this always the case?) It is likely that sending audience as an array will not be correctly interpreted by existing software, so this property is an unreliable indicator of context audience membership at best Existing threadiverse apps check addresses, and audience may not be used at all in some. There is no conflict with Move(Person), and I have not heard a convincing reason to adopt a new activity type when these two AS activities work quite well to describe what we want to accomplish.
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    10 Views
    Week in Fediverse 2025-12-26Servers- Hollo v0.6.19- Iceshrimp.NET v2025.1-beta5.patch3.security4- Mitra v4.15.0- Manyfold v0.130.2- stegodon v1.3.0- PieFed v1.4.0- Lemmy v0.19.15- Ktistec v3.2.5- Misskey v2025.12.2- Castopod v1.13.8- ActivityPub for WordPress v7.8.2- NeoDB v0.12.6- NodeBB v4.7.2- SquidCity: A tiny ActivityPub (Fediverse) server, written in NodeJS/TypescriptClients- Tusker v2025.4- Photon v2.2.2- Thunder v0.8.3- Holos: A Fediverse client that turns your smartphone into a complete ActivityPub serverFor developers- BotKit v0.3.1- Fedify v1.10.0- apkit v0.3.5- FEP MCP: An MCP (Model Context Protocol) server that provides access to Fediverse Enhancement ProposalsProtocol- FEP-0151: NodeInfo in Fediverse Software (2025 edition) (Final comments)Articles- My 2026 Open Social Web Predictions-----#WeekInFediverse #Fediverse #ActivityPubPrevious edition: https://mitra.social/objects/019b384b-9d7a-abda-7227-014207339cc2
  • 0 Votes
    1 Posts
    9 Views
    Sharing a blog post from a Japanese developer, re: #ActivityPub amase.cc/articles/en/...Why don't recommend to impleme...