How defibrillators work in movies:
-
@drmaddkap who hurt you?
@book The same person who decided to put “shot of adrenaline through the chest into the heart” as part of a movie.
That’s not life saving. That’s instant death. Rupture the heart wall, quick bleed out.
-
How defibrillators work in movies:
“There’s no pulse. CLEAR! *zap* Oh thank God, he’s coming back.”
How defibrillators work in real life:
“He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
@drmaddkap CPR in films: clean, pretty, reliable
CPR in real life: you probably just broke a rib, you're tired by the second set, and there's still no/weak pulse. Oh and that snoring? Yeah, that's agonal breathing. They're not back yet. Keep going.
-
@drmaddkap CPR in films: clean, pretty, reliable
CPR in real life: you probably just broke a rib, you're tired by the second set, and there's still no/weak pulse. Oh and that snoring? Yeah, that's agonal breathing. They're not back yet. Keep going.
And the outcomes are terrible. No one walks out of the hospital IF they survive CPR.
I hate medical procedurals' clean endings.
-
@book The same person who decided to put “shot of adrenaline through the chest into the heart” as part of a movie.
That’s not life saving. That’s instant death. Rupture the heart wall, quick bleed out.
@drmaddkap @book
Sometimes I give myself a shot of adrenaline through the chest just to feel something -
@book The same person who decided to put “shot of adrenaline through the chest into the heart” as part of a movie.
That’s not life saving. That’s instant death. Rupture the heart wall, quick bleed out.
@drmaddkap @book See also : Gunshot wounds in movies. Sure, that little dressing will fix you up nicely. Of course you'll be able to run, jump and fight with no issues what so ever :D
-
And the outcomes are terrible. No one walks out of the hospital IF they survive CPR.
I hate medical procedurals' clean endings.
@BenHM3 @eviljackcarver @drmaddkap so while the odds are terrible *I* did!
(Out of hospital cardiac arrest, CPR & defib by some Marines (randomly). Heart bypass. Walked (very slowly) out of the hospital three and a half weeks later. Still alive & kicking 7 years on)
-
And the outcomes are terrible. No one walks out of the hospital IF they survive CPR.
I hate medical procedurals' clean endings.
@BenHM3 @eviljackcarver @drmaddkap Some survive, but not all that many. I do remember admitting a patient to ITU from the operating theatre recovery after a successful restart of his heart, thinking it would be doom and gloom in the morning. When I arrived, he was just getting back from the shower.
-
@drmaddkap @book See also : Gunshot wounds in movies. Sure, that little dressing will fix you up nicely. Of course you'll be able to run, jump and fight with no issues what so ever :D
@PeteLittle @drmaddkap @book Black Knight: It's only a scratch!
-
How defibrillators work in movies:
“There’s no pulse. CLEAR! *zap* Oh thank God, he’s coming back.”
How defibrillators work in real life:
“He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
@drmaddkap Don't defibrilators do a lot fancier stuff than just that?
> “He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
"My Robot Buddy the Defibrillator" or something. -
@book The same person who decided to put “shot of adrenaline through the chest into the heart” as part of a movie.
That’s not life saving. That’s instant death. Rupture the heart wall, quick bleed out.
I injected adrenaline once, thanks Hunter S. Thompson. It floored me. I never did it again.
-
@drmaddkap CPR in films: clean, pretty, reliable
CPR in real life: you probably just broke a rib, you're tired by the second set, and there's still no/weak pulse. Oh and that snoring? Yeah, that's agonal breathing. They're not back yet. Keep going.
@eviljackcarver I figure there's good reason why, in actual first aid classes covering CPR, the instructor will reiterate "keep doing CPR until the ambulance arrives and trained medics take over".
-
How defibrillators work in movies:
“There’s no pulse. CLEAR! *zap* Oh thank God, he’s coming back.”
How defibrillators work in real life:
“He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
@drmaddkap With all due respect, I say this as someone who spent twenty minutes dead and is only alive due to CPR and a defibrillator?
Bullshit.
-
@drmaddkap With all due respect, I say this as someone who spent twenty minutes dead and is only alive due to CPR and a defibrillator?
Bullshit.
@digitalraven @drmaddkap You were insanely lucky! The survival rate for CPR/defib is not great: around 7-8% of patients on whom rescus is attempted survive to see hospital discharge.
It's still worth doing, but most media portrayals are very misleading.
-
@digitalraven @drmaddkap You were insanely lucky! The survival rate for CPR/defib is not great: around 7-8% of patients on whom rescus is attempted survive to see hospital discharge.
It's still worth doing, but most media portrayals are very misleading.
@cstross @drmaddkap I'm aware of how lucky I am, but 7-8% is way better than 0% and I'd rather people try than assume it won't ever work.
-
How defibrillators work in movies:
“There’s no pulse. CLEAR! *zap* Oh thank God, he’s coming back.”
How defibrillators work in real life:
“He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
@drmaddkap Does sticking nails through one’s hand stave off death like in Bladerunner?
-
How defibrillators work in movies:
“There’s no pulse. CLEAR! *zap* Oh thank God, he’s coming back.”
How defibrillators work in real life:
“He’s asystole. Call it. Time of death 5:23PM”
@drmaddkap also in film: no broken ribs
-
undefined oblomov@sociale.network shared this topic on