@Edent what's so bad about <div> ... or: Why do you want to avoid them?
-
@Edent In the loft running as a relay:
Heltec V3 from Amazon
Case from Etsy that looks 3D printed
Antenna from ThePiHut (https://thepihut.com/products/lora-antenna-with-pigtail-868mhz-black)
Powered using PoE over ethernet plugged into a PoE to USB-C splitter. No networking over the ethernet, just a way to get power into the loft.Client device is a T1000-E (https://thepihut.com/products/sensecap-card-tracker-t1000-e-for-meshtastic) connected over bluetooth to my iPhone.
The firmware running on the relay is super stable. The T1000-E firmware is not as stable and I often have to reboot it every 2 or so days.
@dan @Edent I gave up on both Meshtastic and Meshcore.
(Ran MT for ~3 mo, and MC for ~6 mo)
Meshtastic was largely dead in our area (might have better luck in a more built up area).
Meshcore seemed to be mainly somewhere for people to talk about Meshcore and send “Test!” “RX” messages back and forth.
Unless you have a known, stable, local mesh I wouldn’t rely on either for emergency use…
-
@Edent Neither are actually open source, I used Meshtastic for a year. Great for cities / festivals / mucking around.
Been using meshcore the last year or so.
Meshcore is MUCH more reliable for permanent setups, and usable for long range. We have like 200 meshcore nodes covering our whole state. Regularly messaging people hundreds of km away 12-14 hops.
This would be impossible on Meshtastic. -
@Edent Neither are actually open source, I used Meshtastic for a year. Great for cities / festivals / mucking around.
Been using meshcore the last year or so.
Meshcore is MUCH more reliable for permanent setups, and usable for long range. We have like 200 meshcore nodes covering our whole state. Regularly messaging people hundreds of km away 12-14 hops.
This would be impossible on Meshtastic.@Edent I dislike Andy Kirby, and he’s investing in / building meshcore with a kiwi dev called Liam. Expecting enshittification in the future.
I trust Meshtastic devs even less 😅 -
@Edent from my (limited) experience, Meshtastic is better for telemetry-sending, and messaging is a side effect that people have grabbed hold of. As a result short-range comms work well. Meshcore is designed to be more of a message relaying system. Meshcore also has much longer range because of the relays. The cluster I participate in reaches from Hull to Isle of Wight.
-
@Edent from my (limited) experience, Meshtastic is better for telemetry-sending, and messaging is a side effect that people have grabbed hold of. As a result short-range comms work well. Meshcore is designed to be more of a message relaying system. Meshcore also has much longer range because of the relays. The cluster I participate in reaches from Hull to Isle of Wight.
@Edent saw you asking elsewhere what people had bought. Here's my heltec V3 with a "10db antenna". It lives behind the velux blind in our bedroom.
-
@Edent I've attended this seession a few days ago: https://techwerkers.nl/en/events/2026-01-15/
It was recorded.
They recommend MeshCore over Meshtastic.
-
@Edent I've attended this seession a few days ago: https://techwerkers.nl/en/events/2026-01-15/
It was recorded.
They recommend MeshCore over Meshtastic.
@pini thank you - that's useful.
-
@krahabors thanks. Any particular device you recommend?
@Edent I do not have anything new or fancy, I'm sure there will be better recommendations.
-
@Edent @krahabors you have devices aimed at running of grid as a repeater. Then you need a low power device. heltec t114 will do, there are many more of course
If you have a device on constant USB power, or battery that should last a day heltecv3 or v4 are fine. -
@Edent I do not have anything new or fancy, I'm sure there will be better recommendations.
@krahabors I'm not interested in new or fancy. I just like tried and tested.
-
@krahabors @Edent I don't know what an nrf controller is.
But I am learning: https://howtomechatronics.com/tutorials/arduino/arduino-wireless-communication-nrf24l01-tutorial/#transmitter-codeBut there are low power firmware variants. https://github.com/dt267/MeshCore-Low-Power-Firmware-For-Heltec-V3-V4
However for beginners (like me also) just stick to normal firmware.
-
@krahabors I'm not interested in new or fancy. I just like tried and tested.
@Edent DIY combination of nrf52840 with sx1262, usually called faketec, is good enough for me. Even without common PCB, wired dead-bug style:)
There are factory made versions of that combination now and a lot of newer, probably better options. -
@krahabors @Edent I don't know what an nrf controller is.
But I am learning: https://howtomechatronics.com/tutorials/arduino/arduino-wireless-communication-nrf24l01-tutorial/#transmitter-codeBut there are low power firmware variants. https://github.com/dt267/MeshCore-Low-Power-Firmware-For-Heltec-V3-V4
However for beginners (like me also) just stick to normal firmware.
-
id=CodeSmellOverlay
class=CodeSmellOverlay -
@Edent smells ripe for a custom ad block rule
-
@Edent I don't know if Benn Jordan has a presence on Mastodon, but I'm sure he'd have something to say on the subject. ..
-
@Edent I'm on #meshcore because that looks to be more active in my area. (Netherlands)
I sarted with 25 euro investment for a helltec v3 (3.2 iirc) and I learned a ton about wireless signals already. I am planning to build a repeater to get the network more stable and put that out on the balcony where I live.
I'm having fun but it's still very new. It feels like proper emergency comms are still with the hams, but then I need to get a license.
Highly subjective takes, all of this. 😊Learning
-
@Edent
I put up a meshtastic node before xmas. It's currently down though while I improve the power supply. I'm in the countryside. -
@Edent
Well. At least the developer is aware. -
@Edent I'm on #meshcore because that looks to be more active in my area. (Netherlands)
I sarted with 25 euro investment for a helltec v3 (3.2 iirc) and I learned a ton about wireless signals already. I am planning to build a repeater to get the network more stable and put that out on the balcony where I live.
I'm having fun but it's still very new. It feels like proper emergency comms are still with the hams, but then I need to get a license.
Highly subjective takes, all of this. 😊Learning
@CommissarBas cheers.