Wem muss ich hier folgen um sowas in meinem Feed zu sehen, war völlig an mir vorbei gegangen 😬

[tobi82@swiss.social]

Wem muss ich hier folgen um sowas in meinem Feed zu sehen, war völlig an mir vorbei gegangen 😬

https://github.com/minio/minio/commit/27742d469462e1561c776f88ca7a1f26816d69e2

#minio

[larsmb@mastodon.online]

@tobi82 Ich bin ziemlich sicher, in der Vergangenheit mehrfach über MinIO gesprochen zu haben, aber vermutlich geht das in der Menge unter ...

[tobi82@swiss.social]

@larsmb

Vielleicht über Weihnachten, da war ich nicht viel online 🤔

[recoveredexpert@mastodon.social]

@tobi82 Weiss nicht wann @larsmb was dazu geschrieben hab, aber in meiner Timeline hatte ich schon im weit vor Weihnachten Posts dazu. Viele haben sich Alternativen wie Garage oder SeaweedFS angeschaut. Kann mich erinnern das @stefano und @jwildeboer auch dazu Blog Artikel dazu hatten.

[stefano@mastodon.bsd.cafe]

@RecoveredExpert @tobi82 @larsmb @jwildeboer I moved from Minio to SeaweedFS. After testing Garage and SeaweedFS for many small files (the BSD Cafe media), I found that SeaweedFS is (was?) much more performant, for that specific workload. I've written something about it: https://it-notes.dragas.net/2025/11/06/self-hosting-your-mastodon-media-with-seaweedfs/

[tobi82@swiss.social]

@stefano @RecoveredExpert @larsmb @jwildeboer

Thanks. 🙏 I will check it out. I need to migrate an eGovernment solution that is currently using min.io as S3 storage.

Performance is not our main concern, but reliability and data integrity. The docs I found so far are not very detailed regarding the cluster setup (kubernetes), let’s see.

Did you found any best practices regarding this?

[larsmb@mastodon.online]

@tobi82 @stefano @RecoveredExpert @jwildeboer For an eGovernment solution with reliability needs, I'd consider giving a company like Clyso a call about getting Ceph deployed.

Neither garage nor Seaweedfs have truly commercial backing, as far as I can tell.

Though it's worth pointing out that Chainguard has forked minio and is continuing to maintain it in exchange for cash, too.

[tobi82@swiss.social]

@larsmb @stefano @RecoveredExpert @jwildeboer

I wanted to avoid looking for additional budget due to the complexity in such a project.

The s3 is needed to hold attachment files of messages transported via Kafka or rest interfaces. The data needs to be stored a maximum of 7 days. It’s deleted as soon as the Kafka message is processed.

I was hoping for a solution that is simple enough to be managed by the devops or Kafka team. 😬

[larsmb@mastodon.online]

@tobi82 @stefano @RecoveredExpert @jwildeboer garage is really quite easy to use then.

I don't use Seaweedfs because it's a single developer effectively (though a highly motivated one) and chose a weakly protective license. And it tries to do too much for my taste.

[tobi82@swiss.social]

@larsmb @stefano @RecoveredExpert @jwildeboer

Thanks for the information. Yes a single developer solution won’t do it. I will do a classic evaluation then and search a widely adapted and supported solution.

[jwildeboer@social.wildeboer.net]

@tobi82 Feel free to read up at https://garagehq.deuxfleurs.fr/documentation/cookbook/ and the integrations part on how Garage is used in practice. My blog series focuses on homelab use, so I guess nit really of interest to you: https://jan.wildeboer.net/2026/01/1-Local-S3-With-Garage/ Cephfs as S3 is quite a common use case and Ceph comes with support (though not cheap ;) @larsmb @stefano @RecoveredExpert