"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
-
they claim "Zero exposure to original source" but surely all popular Open Source projects have been read and parsed by every LLM in existence many times over
@bagder So this is logical conclusion of the python chardet library re-license.
Getting a court to rule is probably the only way to get a answer one way or another, but getting the LLMs to say definitively what is in the training set will probably be hard (claimed trade secrets).
Even if it's satire it won't be long
-
@bagder This is clearly satire
@clementd @bagder You'd think, but it follows on from his talk on it.. https://fosdem.org/2026/schedule/speaker/mike_nolan/
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder Aptly named!
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder Nice trolling, but I'm puzzled, what happens if you pay? The stripe checkout page is real. Wouldn't that be considered scamming then?
-
so yeah, I would say that this is most likely satire
@bagder Their blog: "Some will argue that what we do is exploitative, that we are extracting the ideas from open source while leaving behind the people who contributed them. To this I say: yes, that is a reasonably accurate description of our business model. It is also a reasonably accurate description of [...] virtually every company that has ever used open source software. We are simply being honest about it, and charging a fee for the privilege."
Must be satire indeed
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder April 1st gets earlier every year, right?
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder@mastodon.social
waow
SaaS (Stealing as a Service) -
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder lol "LLM doing something from scratch" is literally contradictio in adiecto. :D
-
so yeah, I would say that this is most likely satire
@bagder are you saying that Dr. Heinrich Offshore isn’t a real person?!
-
@bagder April 1st gets earlier every year, right?
I also got tricked until I read the "AGPL contamination" snippet:)
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder Finally I can fulfill my lifelong dream of reimplementing curl in a weekend!
-
@bagder I sure as fuck hope so, because that page makes me sick.
-
so yeah, I would say that this is most likely satire
@bagder It's good satire. I'm glad you boosted it.
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder I'm pretty sure this is just a joke
-
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder concept tried and tested in production, to the joy of many: https://github.com/chardet/chardet/pull/322/files [ https://github.com/chardet/chardet/issues/327 ] with improvement metrics also generated by the LLM: https://github.com/chardet/chardet/commit/59b0e4a25a0edcfa2bd61d3cc34b96fe9ef71b59
-
@bagder is copyright still a thing ... I thought it got blown up with llm ? lets wait till oracle database source is recreated ... maybe opinions will change.
@jimfuller whoever told you that was misinformed
-
so yeah, I would say that this is most likely satire
@bagder The "Through our offshore subsidiary in a jurisdiction that doesn't recognize software copyright" asterisk is just *chef's kiss*
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder that was a nice one! a little bit _too_ obvious, but nice.
OTOH, recently i came across https://www.shiftify.us and read it as SHITTIFY and also thought that was a parody:
"Shiftify gives your team everything it needs to hire, manage, and retain a high-performing workforce with AI-driven compliance and precision in healthcare, biotech, government, and beyond."
but it probably wasn't a parody, but something real.
-
"Our proprietary AI robots independently recreate any open source project from scratch"
@bagder I couldn't tell if this was satire or real. Searching, I think it's satire related to the fosdem talk on this subject.
It's horrifying to think that there are real people who actually think like the points listed on the site, even if the site itself isn't real