Mozilla is soliciting feedback on AI in Firefox and the community is delivering.

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

Mozilla is soliciting feedback on AI in Firefox and the community is delivering.

https://connect.mozilla.org/t5/discussions/building-ai-the-firefox-way-shaping-what-s-next-together/td-p/109922

#ai #firefox #mozilla

[npars01@mstdn.social]

@amoroso

The feedback is mostly various renditions of "Absolutely not!" and "Heck no!"

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@Npars01 I suspect Mozilla's leadership will interpret the feddback as "Absolutely yes!" and "Go ahead!".

[kroc@oldbytes.space]

@amoroso @Npars01 “We heard you,”

*proceeds to do exactly what they were planning to do anyway

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@Kroc Which is technically correct as they do hear the loud feedback.

@Npars01

[phf@mastodon.de]

@amoroso They let you type a reply and THEN ask for a login. And when you "back" because you're not gonna, your reply is gone. Which is the worst kind of infuriating. I now imagine myself floating in space, looking at the giant M monolith saying "My god, it's full of a******s..."

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@phf I sign in with the same Mozilla ID I use for syncing Firefox but yes, it's infuriating.

[mikro2nd@indieweb.social]

@amoroso
Thing is... just follow the money. And the money wants "AI", so Mozilla has no choice but to follow if they want to keep paying their execs outrageous salaries.

[mina@berlin.social]

@amoroso

There was one short and on the point reply by a user named "nube":

»Mozilla, get it: you can't compete with chromium, you can't target a mainstream audience, you can't win. You're just going to lose us, the little audience you still have, stop making fun of your users!«

That's the point: #FireFox is a boutique browser nowadays. Its only way of staying in the game is by being substantially different from Chrome and its clones.

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@mikro2nd They could at least spare us the patronizing.

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@mina Spot on.

[ploum@mamot.fr]

@amoroso : could not find a single enthusiastic comment.

If we, anti-AI people, were so niche minority, where’s all that silent majority ?

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@ploum I could fine only one comment mostly in favor, plus 6 kudos so far for the original post. Which, given the rest of the feedback, backs your point.

[amcjen@hachyderm.io]

@amoroso Wow, their arrogance is off the charts.

“We hear you about not wanting AI, but ‘waves hands about technology moving forward’ and we’ve decided we’re the best team to tell you how you’ll use the technology you said you didn’t want to use”

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@amcjen Indeed.

[niavy@masto.bike]

@amoroso

Two words : DEFAULT OPT-OUT

#ai #firefox #mozilla

[amberage@eldritch.cafe]

@amoroso aaaaand added my 2c. Also, does the announcement read "AI"-generated to anyone else or just me?! What the fuck.

[silvermoon82@wandering.shop]

@amoroso
In the entire first page of replies, I see one "I want it to be different" and every other response is "I don't want it at all".
I don't understand why leadership wants this so badly. I mean, I joke about CEOs who chose a shirt size at age 19 and now are fatter and hypoxic, but is that really it? Is there some other property inherent to the C-suite that makes them bad at decisions?

[hectorjcorrea@mastodon.social]

@amoroso I love your reply:

"The only AI related thing I want is a single, prominent, easily accessible switch to turn off absolutely all opt-out AI features. No chasing about:config entries."

[amoroso@oldbytes.space]

@niavy Agreed.