What an announcement from #Telegram owner Pawel Durov!
-
What an announcement from #Telegram owner Pawel Durov! To provide just a few critical notes, he
- makes believe he is just a commoner, and not the billionaire owner of one of the largest message, media and metadata *cleartext* databases on earth
- skips over Global Warming
- refers to "fathers and forefathers" of the Internet ... apparently never heard of Radia Perlman, Margaret Hamilton or Ada Lovelace?
- conveniently excludes Russia and its authoritarian politics from his critique
etc.
-
What an announcement from #Telegram owner Pawel Durov! To provide just a few critical notes, he
- makes believe he is just a commoner, and not the billionaire owner of one of the largest message, media and metadata *cleartext* databases on earth
- skips over Global Warming
- refers to "fathers and forefathers" of the Internet ... apparently never heard of Radia Perlman, Margaret Hamilton or Ada Lovelace?
- conveniently excludes Russia and its authoritarian politics from his critique
etc.
-
undefined Marco Bresciani shared this topic on
-
He addressed these complaints years ago, the summary is:
Social networks are as useful as how many people use them. So they need to attract people. Technically it is very difficult to provide features that attract people by using e2ee, decentralization, donations etc.
He thinks he can be an enlightened patron and being able to protect himself from power. He has the money to do this particular attempt.
1/2
-
He addressed these complaints years ago, the summary is:
Social networks are as useful as how many people use them. So they need to attract people. Technically it is very difficult to provide features that attract people by using e2ee, decentralization, donations etc.
He thinks he can be an enlightened patron and being able to protect himself from power. He has the money to do this particular attempt.
1/2
And let's admit Telegram is not the reason things like Matrix, Delta, XMPP are not more popular. It's just that it is nearly impossible to make them as popular as Telegram because of what people are today.
Durov just sent a valuable message to 1+ billion of people today and it is not appreciated because he didn't the same with e2ee, decentralization, DEI terminology and without being a billionaire.
2/2
-
And let's admit Telegram is not the reason things like Matrix, Delta, XMPP are not more popular. It's just that it is nearly impossible to make them as popular as Telegram because of what people are today.
Durov just sent a valuable message to 1+ billion of people today and it is not appreciated because he didn't the same with e2ee, decentralization, DEI terminology and without being a billionaire.
2/2
@alxlg @adbenitez end-to-end encryption and decentralization are at the very core of achieving resilient and private Internet messaging. Good intents and big ethical claims are not sufficient. Relying on Durov and all of Telegram's sysadmins to never ever do database queries and hand over data to some high bidder is a tenuous assumption.
We need architectures, practises and licenses that grant a right to exit for users and devs, to materially prevent enshittification and selling out users.
-
undefined Oblomov shared this topic on
Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
Post suggeriti
-
-
Su #Telegram appare una notifica mandata direttamente da #paveldurov che, seppur possa condividere la preoccupazione di fondo, messa in questo modo puzza terribilmente di #guerraibrida.
Uncategorized1
-
-
Ti chiedi come far sapere ai tuoi amici che usi #Signal?๐Aggiungi il badge Anche Su Signal sulla tua foto profilo di #WhatsApp e #Telegramโจ Qui trovi lo strumento apposito, ora anche in italiano!
Uncategorized1