Would you like to see full default interoperability between #ATproto and #ActivityPub without a bridge?
Senza categoria
37
Post
6
Autori
0
Visualizzazioni
-
Would you like to see full default interoperability between #ATproto and #ActivityPub without a bridge? (what's preventing this...)
-
Would you like to see full default interoperability between #ATproto and #ActivityPub without a bridge? (what's preventing this...)
@wjmaggos That doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want Chinese and Spanish to be mutually intelligible. You could try to combine the two languages into one mixed thing, but that resulting language would be neither Chinese nor Spanish.
-
@wjmaggos That doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want Chinese and Spanish to be mutually intelligible. You could try to combine the two languages into one mixed thing, but that resulting language would be neither Chinese nor Spanish.
@evan @wjmaggos you're making a category error, Evan.
People who aren't us don't give even the tiniest shits about which protocols they're using. 5G phones happily talk to 2G phones over SS7, and the only thing anyone knows about "5G" is that it's "fast" – and they don't even know what that means.
You just said approx. "that doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want NG-RAN and SS7 to be mutually intelligible" and people will care about as much as someone who literally says that.
-
@evan @wjmaggos you're making a category error, Evan.
People who aren't us don't give even the tiniest shits about which protocols they're using. 5G phones happily talk to 2G phones over SS7, and the only thing anyone knows about "5G" is that it's "fast" – and they don't even know what that means.
You just said approx. "that doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want NG-RAN and SS7 to be mutually intelligible" and people will care about as much as someone who literally says that.
@evan @wjmaggos (i.e. not at all)
It makes plenty sense to make BlueSky and Mastodon interoperable, even if it involves protocol-level translation. Doing so is, frankly, easy, and much easier than the very common approach of translating between Spanish and Chinese (which is what we normally do to communicate instead of inventing a Spanish/Chinese pidgin, which is also a thing humans do!).
-
@wjmaggos That doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want Chinese and Spanish to be mutually intelligible. You could try to combine the two languages into one mixed thing, but that resulting language would be neither Chinese nor Spanish.
evan@cosocial.ca wjmaggos@liberal.city clearly what we need is one final protocol to rule them all /s
-
@evan @wjmaggos (i.e. not at all)
It makes plenty sense to make BlueSky and Mastodon interoperable, even if it involves protocol-level translation. Doing so is, frankly, easy, and much easier than the very common approach of translating between Spanish and Chinese (which is what we normally do to communicate instead of inventing a Spanish/Chinese pidgin, which is also a thing humans do!).
@evan @wjmaggos where the real "human-level" challenge is is that e.g. Mastodon and BlueSky are different, culturally, and so are "the Fediverse" and "Truth Social" and any combination of separate servers that we can imagine, or even two random servers *within* the Mastodon-running-Fediverse. Mastodon and Bluesky are way more similar than Pixelfed, and it makes much less sense to federate Pixelfed and Mastodon than it does Mastodon and Bluesky, because they serve different social purposes.
-
@evan @wjmaggos where the real "human-level" challenge is is that e.g. Mastodon and BlueSky are different, culturally, and so are "the Fediverse" and "Truth Social" and any combination of separate servers that we can imagine, or even two random servers *within* the Mastodon-running-Fediverse. Mastodon and Bluesky are way more similar than Pixelfed, and it makes much less sense to federate Pixelfed and Mastodon than it does Mastodon and Bluesky, because they serve different social purposes.
-
-
@evan @wjmaggos (i.e. not at all)
It makes plenty sense to make BlueSky and Mastodon interoperable, even if it involves protocol-level translation. Doing so is, frankly, easy, and much easier than the very common approach of translating between Spanish and Chinese (which is what we normally do to communicate instead of inventing a Spanish/Chinese pidgin, which is also a thing humans do!).
-
-
@evan @wjmaggos you're making a category error, Evan.
People who aren't us don't give even the tiniest shits about which protocols they're using. 5G phones happily talk to 2G phones over SS7, and the only thing anyone knows about "5G" is that it's "fast" – and they don't even know what that means.
You just said approx. "that doesn't make any sense; it's like saying that you want NG-RAN and SS7 to be mutually intelligible" and people will care about as much as someone who literally says that.
-
@evan @wjmaggos it's not my message. My message to technologists was "the key piece of interop for humans is identity" and I was told "webfinger isn't part of activitypub" and "domain names are how we do identity on the internet" (despite the idea that paying $25/year to get to manage DNS isn't an end-user-achievable thing in the world we live in) and after years of this I gave up. It makes me sad that Bluesky went with domain names because consistent format really matters, but 🤷♂️
-
-
@evan @wjmaggos it's not my message. My message to technologists was "the key piece of interop for humans is identity" and I was told "webfinger isn't part of activitypub" and "domain names are how we do identity on the internet" (despite the idea that paying $25/year to get to manage DNS isn't an end-user-achievable thing in the world we live in) and after years of this I gave up. It makes me sad that Bluesky went with domain names because consistent format really matters, but 🤷♂️
@blaine @wjmaggos Webfinger isn't part of ActivityPub, it's true. It is one of the key technologies that we use as part of the stack, though, which is why we have a whole Report about WF + AP.
I don't see any reason why you couldn't add someone's BlueSky account to a Webfinger descriptor. It would be extremely useful for lookup! Do you know if any work has been done on a link-rel for BlueSky addresses?
-
so don't we have to propose visions and see which ones make the most sense, are most popular, are compatible?
what's special about social media is the boost. virality. not community or the public square. making it decentralized without algos or ads puts the people fully in control. collectively we can determine what info, ideas and art gets the most attention. I think that's the revolution @rabble talks about. I call it #DemocracyOfReach.
which protocol makes that most likely?
-
so don't we have to propose visions and see which ones make the most sense, are most popular, are compatible?
what's special about social media is the boost. virality. not community or the public square. making it decentralized without algos or ads puts the people fully in control. collectively we can determine what info, ideas and art gets the most attention. I think that's the revolution @rabble talks about. I call it #DemocracyOfReach.
which protocol makes that most likely?
-
@blaine @wjmaggos The first question asked by the poll is "Would you like to see full default interoperability between #ATproto and #ActivityPub without a bridge?"
The second question is "what's preventing this".
-
@blaine @wjmaggos The first question asked by the poll is "Would you like to see full default interoperability between #ATproto and #ActivityPub without a bridge?"
The second question is "what's preventing this".
@evan @wjmaggos you're reading it as a technologist – I agree with you that making atproto and activitypub literally interoperable is ... weird (although, I have argued many times that I think the two protocols will converge in functionality and scope, and also separately that lens-based translation of data structures is basically the best thing and would smooth right over the lexicon/AS differences if we had good tooling).
-
@evan @wjmaggos you're reading it as a technologist – I agree with you that making atproto and activitypub literally interoperable is ... weird (although, I have argued many times that I think the two protocols will converge in functionality and scope, and also separately that lens-based translation of data structures is basically the best thing and would smooth right over the lexicon/AS differences if we had good tooling).
@evan @wjmaggos ... but that's not what the question is asking. It's intent, and the #atproto and #activitypub in the question aren't referring to specifications, they're referring to communities.
-
@evan @wjmaggos ... but that's not what the question is asking. It's intent, and the #atproto and #activitypub in the question aren't referring to specifications, they're referring to communities.
Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
-
@cvtsi2sd
"Hash value" e se lo traducessimo con "valore espresso"?
@sabrinaweb71 @itanglese @ItaLinuxSociety @linux @opensource
-
La BCE consiglia il contante...
https://mastodon.uno/@piratepost@poliverso.org/115277741677034044
https://poliverso.org/display/0477a01e-1568-d830-ce57-564058750971
-
-
@sabrinaweb71
Spapocciato è stupendo. E se anche fosse un neologismo, evviva i neologismi. 😁
@cvtsi2sd @itanglese @ItaLinuxSociety @linux @opensource
-
La Bce invita ad avere contanti: “Cruciali durante le crisi”. Quanti tenerne in casa?
Il contante è uno strumento “essenziale” per gestire i periodi di crisi, al punto che le autorità di diversi Paesi suggeriscono di “dotarsi di una riserva di contanti che consenta di effettuare gli acquisti essenziali per diversi giorni”: per esempio “le autorità di Paesi Bassi, Austria e Finlandia suggeriscono di detenere importi compresi approssimativamente fra 70 e 100 euro per ogni membro della famiglia, o sufficienti a coprire i bisogni essenziali per circa 72 ore”. A scriverlo è la Banca centrale Europa, nel suo bollettino economico, in cui è presente un’analisi titolata: “Keep calm and carry cash: indicazioni tratte da quattro crisi sul ruolo unico della moneta fisica”.
-
@matz
Si infatti non funziona. E nemmeno con Peertube 😅😭
-
saputnik (@saputnik.bsky.social)
https://bsky.app/profile/saputnik.bsky.social/post/3lztme4wyi22f
Un’epidemia migliaia e migliaia di sale scommesse, anche nei villaggi più sperduti. #photography
-
se vi va, possiamo fare un AMA su identità digitale. Basta che ci siano un po' di partecipanti, diciamo una trentina...
