Posting about my Mastodon Relay again, registration is open so feel free to add it (location of the relay is US East Coast).
-
@julian Hmm, it seems the software I'm using has non-Public hard setting that isn't configurable on /actor, so I don't think it's compatible with your instance unless I can figure out a way to lax those settings 🤔
incentive@mastodon.circlewithadot.net can you share more information? What's a "non-public hard setting"?
Also, what software are you using? I have mainly tested against Aoderelay, but I should be compatible with others too :)
-
@julian I'm using https://github.com/yukimochi/Activity-Relay, and the error I'm getting is "relay-server | ERRO[0275] Rejected Follow, Unfollow Request : https://activitypub.space/actor only https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams#Public is allowed to follow"
I think I get the same error when a Friendica instance attempts as well.
-
@julian I'm using https://github.com/yukimochi/Activity-Relay, and the error I'm getting is "relay-server | ERRO[0275] Rejected Follow, Unfollow Request : https://activitypub.space/actor only https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams#Public is allowed to follow"
I think I get the same error when a Friendica instance attempts as well.
incentive@mastodon.circlewithadot.net ooooooh cool, Activity-Relay was one of the relays I was not able to test against... here I thought they were just closed, now I know it's an error!
This is the relevant bit of code after searching their repository... Let's see what I can dig up.
-
@julian I think /relay needs to be added as a valid follower of /actor. I'm going to test a change really quick and see if I break it or not lol
-
@julian I think /relay needs to be added as a valid follower of /actor. I'm going to test a change really quick and see if I break it or not lol
incentive@mastodon.circlewithadot.net The code suggests that when parsing the follow request, it's checking
objectand ensuring that it is one of:https://www.w3.org/ns/activitystreams#Public- It's own ID (so,
https://relay-us-east.circlewithadot.net/actor)
NodeBB is sending
https://relay-us-east.circlewithadot.net/actor, so it should satisfy that constraint, but I am not sure where in the Activity-Relay code it is failing out. -
@julian I rebuilt the docker image with some changes in resolver - you're welcome to try again in the meantime if you wish - if not I can return to this tomorrow :)
Appreciate you looking into this with me.
-
@julian I rebuilt the docker image with some changes in resolver - you're welcome to try again in the meantime if you wish - if not I can return to this tomorrow :)
Appreciate you looking into this with me.
-
@julian Confirmed! "relay-server | INFO[0263] Sent MutuallyFollow Request : https://activitypub.space/actor
relay-server | INFO[0263] RelayState reloaded "🤝
-
@julian Confirmed! "relay-server | INFO[0263] Sent MutuallyFollow Request : https://activitypub.space/actor
relay-server | INFO[0263] RelayState reloaded "🤝
incentive@mastodon.circlewithadot.net so what was the issue, a bug in Activity-Relay?
The LitePub section on FEP-ae0c: Fediverse Relay Protocols: Mastodon and LitePub is pretty vague about deviations from expectations. It would be good to shore up this FEP a bit.
-
@julian All I did was make both /actor and /relay accepted follows from /actor, going through the issues in their repo and you showing me the resolver page is what made me try it. https://github.com/yukimochi/Activity-Relay/issues/90
-
@julian All I did was make both /actor and /relay accepted follows from /actor, going through the issues in their repo and you showing me the resolver page is what made me try it. https://github.com/yukimochi/Activity-Relay/issues/90
@julian Congrats on ActivityPub.space btw- made an account. Looks cool.
-
Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
-
@emmecola personalmente non voglio nemmeno che varese.social sia l’unica istanza del territorio della provincia. Vorrei che ne nascessero il più possibile! Magari una per ogni comune. Recentemente Mastodon ha lanciato la possibilità di gestire l’istanza di enti pubblici tramite il loro team.
Mi piacerebbe moltissimo vedere il mio comune gestire la propria istanza. Comunicazioni ufficiali inviate tramite istanze gestite direttamente dal territorio. Chissà…
https://joinmastodon.org/hosting
-
@piero Penso che il modo più semplice sia parlarne direttamente di persona. Magari potresti consigliare di far iscrivere la persona interessata ad una istanza generalista garantendogli che nel caso volesse cambiare idea può tranquillamente portarsi appresso i seguaci su un’altra istanza. Personale credo che M1 stia centralizzando troppo il fediverso italiano. C’è da dire però che la mia esperienza su M1 mi è servita come per capire i fondamenti del fediverso.
-
@emmecola L’obbiettivo secondo me è: come faccio a promuovere di più le altre istanze?
Nelle info di Varese Social ho una lista in continuo aggiornamento di istanze italiane. Mi piacerebbe pubblicare un piccolo post (magari uno ogni settimana) promuovendo altre istanze del fediverso italiano. Più sono “spalmati” gli utenti e meno gli admin pagano per ospitarli.
Chi punta alla crescita incontrollata è destinato a fallire.
Nel mondo ideale ciascun utente avrebbe la propria istanza autogestita.
-
@emanuelecariati@varese.social Non è la mia domanda. Io tengo le mie istanze chiuse alle iscrizioni perché basta la federazione. La mia domanda è come faccio a fare crescere il Fediverso tenendo chiuse alle iscrizioni le mie istanze?
-
@emanuelecariati La domanda che tutti gli admin si fanno è: come facciamo a fare crescere le nostre istanze? 🙂
-
-
@julian Congrats on ActivityPub.space btw- made an account. Looks cool.
-
@julian All I did was make both /actor and /relay accepted follows from /actor, going through the issues in their repo and you showing me the resolver page is what made me try it. https://github.com/yukimochi/Activity-Relay/issues/90
