🔐 Every unencrypted email is readable by 10+ entities and stored forever.
-
@thedarktangent @yawnbox This article is not about email security but about WKD. I have already written about email security and will likely revisit the topic in the near future.
@nicfab @yawnbox I have lived through essentially the same issues with PGP keys in DNS, hashes of SMime keys in DNS, MTA-STS, DANE for SMTP, automatic SMIME using SMILE, etc.
I hope WKD does better! But I fear that without a solution to local email search it will be a victim of its own success, or you will have to put so much information in the subject line to remind you what is in the encrypted body that some privacy is lost.
-
-
@nicfab @yawnbox I have lived through essentially the same issues with PGP keys in DNS, hashes of SMime keys in DNS, MTA-STS, DANE for SMTP, automatic SMIME using SMILE, etc.
I hope WKD does better! But I fear that without a solution to local email search it will be a victim of its own success, or you will have to put so much information in the subject line to remind you what is in the encrypted body that some privacy is lost.
@thedarktangent @yawnbox I share your concern — past attempts (PGP in DNS, DANE, SMILE, etc.) struggled with adoption. WKD isn’t a complete solution, but it’s worth setting up: it removes a key barrier and makes encrypted mail more usable, even if challenges like local search and subject-line leaks remain.
-
-
🔐 Every unencrypted email is readable by 10+ entities and stored forever.
Web Key Directory (WKD) changes this: automatic encryption using your domain name. No manual keys. No central servers. Just cryptographic certainty.
WKD makes encrypted email as simple as HTTPS made web browsing secure.
https://www.nicfab.eu/en/posts/wkd2/
#WebKeyDirectory #WKD #EmailEncryption #Privacy #InfoSec #Cryptography #OpenPGP
@nicfab
Reading the article, I can't see how this works out in a hybrid situation - where not all your email recipients are using WKD. Am I missing something?
You mention the strength of email being its own prison - we need something that would encrypt where possible, and fall back to plaintext where not (with warning). HTTPS was not implemented across the board overnight. -
@nicfab
Reading the article, I can't see how this works out in a hybrid situation - where not all your email recipients are using WKD. Am I missing something?
You mention the strength of email being its own prison - we need something that would encrypt where possible, and fall back to plaintext where not (with warning). HTTPS was not implemented across the board overnight.@grant_h 1/2 You're right — WKD alone doesn't handle the hybrid scenario. It's just key discovery, not the complete solution.
For opportunistic encryption, you need WKD plus smart clients: Thunderbird, DeltaChat, and others already do this — they check for keys via WKD/Autocrypt, encrypt when possible, and fall back to plaintext with warnings. -
@nicfab
Reading the article, I can't see how this works out in a hybrid situation - where not all your email recipients are using WKD. Am I missing something?
You mention the strength of email being its own prison - we need something that would encrypt where possible, and fall back to plaintext where not (with warning). HTTPS was not implemented across the board overnight.@grant_h 2/2 - Think of it like HTTPS adoption:
- WKD = certificate infrastructure (like Let's Encrypt)
- Autocrypt/client logic = protocol negotiation
- Warnings = mixed content alertsSo yes, the ecosystem supports "encrypt when possible" — WKD makes finding keys automatic. The clients handle the graceful degradation you're looking for.
-
@grant_h 2/2 - Think of it like HTTPS adoption:
- WKD = certificate infrastructure (like Let's Encrypt)
- Autocrypt/client logic = protocol negotiation
- Warnings = mixed content alertsSo yes, the ecosystem supports "encrypt when possible" — WKD makes finding keys automatic. The clients handle the graceful degradation you're looking for.
@nicfab My use case is a school. Teachers and students. Particularly the counselling staff. It has to be easy and seamless, and resetable by our admins.
Unfortunately, the big companies have no incentive to make our email private, and every incentive to make it easy to join. The precise opposite of so many FOSS projects. We will persevere! -
@nicfab My use case is a school. Teachers and students. Particularly the counselling staff. It has to be easy and seamless, and resetable by our admins.
Unfortunately, the big companies have no incentive to make our email private, and every incentive to make it easy to join. The precise opposite of so many FOSS projects. We will persevere!@grant_h Go ahead!
-
🔐 Every unencrypted email is readable by 10+ entities and stored forever.
Web Key Directory (WKD) changes this: automatic encryption using your domain name. No manual keys. No central servers. Just cryptographic certainty.
WKD makes encrypted email as simple as HTTPS made web browsing secure.
https://www.nicfab.eu/en/posts/wkd2/
#WebKeyDirectory #WKD #EmailEncryption #Privacy #InfoSec #Cryptography #OpenPGP
@nicfab @Fr333k Just an observation: that's a long blog post, with a lot of words and with a lot of computer commands and that somewhat contradicts the sentence "WKD makes encrypted email as simple as HTTPS made web browsing secure."
Nothing is simple with OpenPGP and email and that's broadly documented in academia and annecdotes. WKD does not change that.
If you absolutely positively must use email for sending sensitive info, use S/MIME.
-
@nicfab @Fr333k Just an observation: that's a long blog post, with a lot of words and with a lot of computer commands and that somewhat contradicts the sentence "WKD makes encrypted email as simple as HTTPS made web browsing secure."
Nothing is simple with OpenPGP and email and that's broadly documented in academia and annecdotes. WKD does not change that.
If you absolutely positively must use email for sending sensitive info, use S/MIME.
@seecurity @Fr333k You’re right that nothing in email crypto is ever “simple” — WKD doesn’t change the complexity of OpenPGP itself. However, it does solve a particular problem that has long blocked adoption: key discovery.
That doesn’t contradict the analogy with HTTPS — it’s about lowering friction, not erasing complexity.
And yes, S/MIME can be smoother in some contexts, but WKD gives domains a way to make OpenPGP more usable in practice. -
@seecurity @Fr333k You’re right that nothing in email crypto is ever “simple” — WKD doesn’t change the complexity of OpenPGP itself. However, it does solve a particular problem that has long blocked adoption: key discovery.
That doesn’t contradict the analogy with HTTPS — it’s about lowering friction, not erasing complexity.
And yes, S/MIME can be smoother in some contexts, but WKD gives domains a way to make OpenPGP more usable in practice.@nicfab @Fr333k Email crypto is extremely complex and because of this, has plenty of attack surface. We published close to 10 papers in the last seven years attacking email and email encryption with OpenPGP and S/MIME.
I am at the point where I find recommending email encryption to be actively harmful. Metadata leaks all over the place, crypto from the '90s, plaintext fallbacks everywhere, user hate it, in particular the gnupg devs are very toxic, mail client developers lack time and (too often) expertise to implement it properly.
Just use Signal. If you got budget, build an app on top of Signal. Heck, just use WhatsApp. Just don't even try to send sensitive information with email encryption.
-
@nicfab @Fr333k Email crypto is extremely complex and because of this, has plenty of attack surface. We published close to 10 papers in the last seven years attacking email and email encryption with OpenPGP and S/MIME.
I am at the point where I find recommending email encryption to be actively harmful. Metadata leaks all over the place, crypto from the '90s, plaintext fallbacks everywhere, user hate it, in particular the gnupg devs are very toxic, mail client developers lack time and (too often) expertise to implement it properly.
Just use Signal. If you got budget, build an app on top of Signal. Heck, just use WhatsApp. Just don't even try to send sensitive information with email encryption.
It’s true: email crypto has flaws and decades of technical debt. But saying “just use Signal or WhatsApp” trades one problem for another — centralized silos controlled by single entities, which is even worse for long-term resilience, governance, and privacy.
WKD won’t magically fix email, but it removes real barriers and raises the baseline. Abandoning open, federated protocols entirely in favor of walled gardens is not a sustainable path.
-
🔐 Every unencrypted email is readable by 10+ entities and stored forever.
Web Key Directory (WKD) changes this: automatic encryption using your domain name. No manual keys. No central servers. Just cryptographic certainty.
WKD makes encrypted email as simple as HTTPS made web browsing secure.
https://www.nicfab.eu/en/posts/wkd2/
#WebKeyDirectory #WKD #EmailEncryption #Privacy #InfoSec #Cryptography #OpenPGP
@nicfab I already have a webserver for my website using my own domain name, do I need a second one or is it possible to combine this somehow?
Really interesting, first I hear of it. Thanks for sharing it!
-
@nicfab I already have a webserver for my website using my own domain name, do I need a second one or is it possible to combine this somehow?
Really interesting, first I hear of it. Thanks for sharing it!
@chiefbongo WKD is for a single domain name only. They cannot be combined, but you can have multiple WKD configurations for numerous domain names on the server.
Gli ultimi otto messaggi ricevuti dalla Federazione
-
#sumudflotilla #GazaFlotilla #gazasolidarity
https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2025/9/28/amid-the-genocide-in-gaza-the-italian-people-made-us-smile
-
@delawen @Em0nM4stodon @_elena @letsenvision Btw, about Meta Ray-Ban, I have met a friend who bought them and said they detected an obstacle to the right, when it was to the left. I honestly have many reasons not to use Meta, but I defend camera-equipped glasses as an aid, because I'd never like to be treated with suspicion just for my glasses. I already have enough stigma around.
-
Alcuni di voi mi scrivono chiedendo esempi del mio "blocco per manifesta stupidità" su X (o altrove, se necessario). Eccone uno: il beota in questione era anche mio follower. Quindi stupidità in purezza (o al quadrato), direi. Per tabella di equivalenza direi quindi imbecillità.
-
@delawen @Em0nM4stodon @_elena @letsenvision No save/share feature. Just description. The old version had actually the ability to recognize people, but NOT from Internet. To identify John Doe, he had to stand in front of you, let you take pics from different angles, then you could record his name. I personally have never used that function, because where it could be useful to recognise people (conferences) it's impossible to have it work in practice.
-
an example: <a href="http://scripting.com">this</a> is a link. if it displayed as a link it would support linking in this context.
if you type that text into any of the systems you mention you won't see a link.
-
@psychotimmy We long lost that innoncence.
-
@glitch Ho studiato.😉
-
Trump (aka “Donnie Trumpeone”) says Microsoft should fire its global affairs president Lisa Monaco | Reuters https://blog.quintarelli.it/2025/09/trump-says-microsoft-should-fire-its-global-affairs-president-lisa-monaco-reuters/
